And now for some rambling non bio crazy…

May 1, 2009 · 15 Comments

OK, so vee just shared and I (jay, obviously) have stuff to share too (and I will share with you, too, OOHM, if you email, because it has taken me all day today to just write this).  Maybe this is all a bit much sharing of the sad kind, but sometimes you just have to purge.  So here goes.

“Non-bio” makes me think of washing powder, but if pressed, I will use it to refer to myself as the non-birth mother because technically, it is what I am. Maybe I haven’t blogged this before [?] but I was actually brought up by my non-bio mother, because my birth mother died when I was very young.  This in itself is bringing up some weird issues now that I am a mother too, even though I have dealt with her death… vee and I knew this would happen, and it’s sort of manageable but stings sometimes, like a cut does when you put antiseptic on it.  In the same way, it’ll fade.

Trust me.  I am a therapy veteran. I know my mental health better than I should, perhaps.

But that isn’t what I wanted to blog about.  I would use the term “other mother” but it makes me feel kind of secondary, and technically, we are both Bonus Ball’s other mother anyway.  As I said to him the other day, “Hey little lad, I’m your mum. And your other mum.  And she’s your mum too.  And your other mum.”  The poor kid is going to be giddy by the time he can talk, albeit grammatically correct.

Whatever you call it, being the non-bio mum kind of sucks sometimes.

Don’t get me wrong.  I love my boy more than I can ever explain, and the same goes for my wife. I do everything I can do for BB.  I change most of his nappies. I dress him.  I SHH him to sleep.  I make him laugh.  I make it better when he cries. I take zillions of photographs of him. I absolutely love being a mother.

But I cannot feed my child and sometimes that kills me.

Vee has been pumping and freezing milk for a while, mainly because she wants me to have the opportunity to feed him too – at the moment, we’re both SAHMs who work from home; another post for another day – but also because it will allow her to actually leave the house for X amount of time if and when she needs to.  However, I’ve given him two bottles so far and didn’t really like it.  It definitely wasnt that “special time” that breastfeeding is meant to be.  I didn’t really like it because vee felt weird and looked upset, and because BB much prefers the boob – and fuck yeah, I would too.  A boob is way nicer than some specially moulded plastic and rubber-type shit any day.

And yes, I have tried comfort nursing, but I am talking nutrition, people.  I could breastfeed, but only started to entertain the idea when it was too late, and now, I’m too busy with nappies and SHHing and whatever else to induce lactation. So, I’ll just have to live with that.  Mostly, it’s OK but sometimes it’s not.

That’s life, I guess?

While I’m on the rant, I might as well add that I am sick to death of people commenting to me that BB looks like vee, when he looks nothing like her (OK maybe they have the same colour eyes, and similar lips, but that’s where it ends).  She agrees with me on that point, and if they DID look more alike, I wouldn’t be jealous or anything; that’s not what this is about at all; besides, vee is very gorgeous indeed, so that’d be great.  It’s just that – like vee said – if they were the spitting image of each other, would be understandable if people uttered stuff without thinking, but they really aren’t.

Somehow, it feels kind of rude, a bit like unneccessarily reinforcing the fact that we aren’t genetically related.  And, like many other weird parenting issues, it does make me wonder if I’ve ever offended someone similarly, because I’m one of those people who loves staring at kids and working out which bits of their faces came from which parent.  But if both of their parents are women, maybe you shouldn’t say anything? Especially not if one of those women is prone to extreme grumpiness?

So, like my Dad often used to say to me as a kid, if you’ve got nothing to say, don’t say it.

This has turned out way longer than it was meant to.  I do apologise. Please ignore me and go back to whatever you were doing before.  For the most part, life is good, and for that, I cannot be more thankful.

Beer. I need beer.

xx jay

Categories: Uncategorized

15 responses so far ↓

  • j.k-c. // May 1, 2009 at 7:48 pm | Reply

    I think that it is an amazing, interesting and sometimes difficult dynamic, this two mom thing.

  • rhetorician // May 1, 2009 at 8:04 pm | Reply

    it’s a tricky item – being someone’s mum in a way that the world doesn’t readily recognise or understand. It doesn’t help me to react too much to others – the people I love and care about absolutely understand my role in C’s life, and I understand that my role in C’s life is distinct and different from her bio mum’s role. I think I owe R that respect for the specific
    physical, emotional and temporal commitment that she makes to C. But I also know that she understands my distinct and different role, and that the non-bio mum’s relationship to her child is unique, and what’s great about it is precisely that it doesn’t fit into society’s ideas about what a mum should be. I don’t know what to tell you really, other than the fact that it is difficult sometimes, and that what you’re feeling is often experienced by the other parent whatever their sex or orientation. I kinda know what you mean about the feeding thing, although most of the time I’m actually grateful that I don’t have to do it! But I know a lot of people do feel the way you do (including several blokes of my acquaintance who found their somewhat peripheral role in the early days really emotionally hard to deal with). But I think parenthood is just hard and full of equivocal feelings, other than the immutable fact that you love your child more than you love your own limbs.

  • Olive // May 1, 2009 at 8:33 pm | Reply

    This is an interesting post – I’m glad you posted it. Even though I’m not a mother yet, I too dislike the term “other mother” and all the similar phrases. It does feel like a lesser category. When I recently went to visit my boss’ baby I commented on how the baby looks like her and then, even though boss received the comment very well, kicked myself. I agree, that with two moms it’s different to make these comments and as fascinating as biology is, these aren’t the comments that need to be made right away. Though I’m not sure how to train others from making them.

    Keep forging this path, I’m sure these are some of the hardest days of non-bio momhood with BB so dependent on Vee for food.

  • hbabypants // May 1, 2009 at 9:30 pm | Reply

    I am really glad you posted this. As we are in the final weeks before the baby is born I have been thinking about this issue (when I am not organizing and re-organizing baby things). I have never liked the “other mother” label, non-bio mom puts the emphasis on biology-which we don’t want to do- and “non-gestational parent” sounds like science fiction. I don’t yet know how we will label ourselves in the outside world.

    There is so much to think about.

  • Whozat // May 1, 2009 at 9:41 pm | Reply

    Of course, our situation is a bit different, especially in terms of the looking-like part of it, since Shrike is Peeper’s genetic mother, but I all the other stuff you said sounds very familiar.

    And from what I hear, many dads feel exactly the same way, in terms of being outside the breastfeeding relationship.

    Keep in mind that, while it’s “his whole life” right now, in the long-run, this will be a very short time, relative to your whole relationship.

    (I know, easy for me to say, with this babe at my breast, huh?)

    Peeper definitely went through a period, around 2 – 3 months old, when she wanted very little to do with anyone but me, which was very hard on both of us.

    Now, although she’s still exclusively breastfeeding (for a few more days at least – a few bits of solids are right around the corner) she’s well past that, and she and Shrike have a good ol’ time without me.

    Right up until she gets hungry, then I’m back on duty :-)

    Also, your last sentence made me giggle a bit.

    I see that both you and Shrike have found one of the major advantages to being the non-gestational and non-breastfeeding mom:

    Beer, and a designated driver!

  • Lizzie // May 1, 2009 at 11:19 pm | Reply

    just wanted to thank you for this post. it’s so tricky, and i’m grateful for you giving voice to it. my only thought (not being a mom yet) is that these differences in relation to BB have got to be the most stark right now, while he literally needs vee for survival. but that as he grows, there will be period of closeness with one or the other of you more, different stages …. as far as these differences in relation to the outside world and how people see you, or react to you, that is where we are pioneers, and it sucks. lots of love & thanks for honesty. (and i also cringe when people say “she looks like you” or “he looks like you” to the bio mom. ack.)

  • mulberry // May 2, 2009 at 2:51 pm | Reply

    like lizzie, i want to thank you for your post as well… i wonder, with dakota’s embryos inside me as i write this… if we are pregnant and we are fortunate enough to have a little baby grow from these embryos, like whosat – the babies will be ‘from’ me, but ‘of’ dakota, and who knows what kinds of emotions that will produce. mostly i feel enormously grateful for the opportunity to (at least try to) create a child that way, but i know that there will be the kinds of moments you talk of… for her, as i breast feed – for me, as her features come to life…

  • Calliope // May 2, 2009 at 3:28 pm | Reply

    brilliant post. I always wondered if the term “other” mother was a good fit for everyone- it seems sort of dismissive. Or even needing to claim one person as bio and the other person as non bio- just feels like an unnecessary divide. You are both the Moms. And maybe now one is the boob mom and one is the nappie/shushing mom- but once this era is past what then? I doubt BB is going to walk around all, “that lady is my bio mom and that one is my non bio mom”.

    Of course as a single gal I probably shouldn’t comment on this- but I hope you don’t mind.

    Now…you say you have been taking loads of photos- I wanna see!!!!!
    xoxo

  • Lo // May 2, 2009 at 8:29 pm | Reply

    Oh, Jay, I have been RIGHT where you are. I’m the “non-bio”, the “other mom”, the NGP. But I couldn’t love this little bugger any more, and like you, I have been there all along. I was there when he was conceived. I caught him on the way out. Without me, he wouldn’t exist; C. and I imagined into being together, chose his donor together. I am still in the process of adopting him and I alternately feel lucky to be allowed, and cross to have to go through such rigmarole to make true what is already so true.

    But as others have said, it gets easier as they get older. It does. They need the boob less. Now, at 16 months, J. has become very connected to me. I feel, in some ways, that I am finally beginning to reap the rewards of the intense engagement we’ve had from the start. (I’ve been meaning to blog about this, maybe I will.) When I pick him up from school, he grins at me and says “Mama!” When he is playing and I am watching him, every so often he will run up and hug my legs or jump in my lap.

    I guess, from where I’m sitting, the best advice I can give is “hang in there.” Sooner than you can imagine, BB will know who you are (he already does; he just can’t show it), and that is what matters most.

  • Amy // May 3, 2009 at 2:47 am | Reply

    i have an interesting perspective and some pretty strong feelings on all of this too. i carried our first baby so never experienced the “ngp” or “non bio” perspective yet was very sensitive to it all of course considering my wife’s feelings. our 2nd baby is 11 weeks old and she carried her. i didn’t realize how brutal it would be to be on the “other” side of the experience. people are so incredibly insensitive. most people are well meaning but man does it sting!!

    all i can say is that our oldest is 3.5 and came from me but you wouldn’t know it based on how she acts and loves. she truly loves us and needs us equally and it’s absolutely wonderful. we both also work from home so are both home with her and now the baby full time, that certainly helps big time!

  • oneofhismoms // May 3, 2009 at 3:32 am | Reply

    I think the breastfeeding is the hardest, suckiest (oh dear, no pun intended, I swear) part. Really. It seems to last forever. I remember being very jealous. It took a great deal of energy to hide my jealousy. I think I did a rotten job of it, to be honest.

    The good news is that in a few months, you’ll be able to feed him baby food. He’ll get it all over your hair.

    But it is hard. I know. I remember.

    BTW, in the book we’re using the term “co-mom.” Since the whole book is about NGPs, we just decided to stick to that term and our readers will know that we’re talking about the non-gestational parent without the “non” or the “other.” You are neither non, nor other my dear.

  • halfadozen // May 4, 2009 at 4:02 pm | Reply

    We totally struggle with these same issues. Our son looks exactly like me, and people have a constant need to say it, esp my family, which is so incredibly insensitive to Jen. We have asked people not to do so and they roll their eyes and act as if we are so oversensitive. when really its them that are so INSENSITIVE.

    I think that it gets a little easier (for us anyway) when the kids get older and the power shifts a bit. When the roles are more malleable and you can share all resposnsibilities evenly. But I think its something we’ll always have to struggle with a bit…

    hugs…

  • L.babypants // May 4, 2009 at 10:09 pm | Reply

    This makes me a bit teary… i am nine months pregnant afterall, but you as far away from non or other as possible and BB is lucky to have you as his mom. I am sure there are some hard bits… and H and I are about to negociate them ourselves. I think the best thing to remember is there would be no BB if not for you and your relationship.. But you know that already – just add my affirmation of that to the stack. xoxo

  • scarredbellybutton // May 5, 2009 at 12:28 pm | Reply

    I use the terms bio/non-bio. What can I say, I do a lot of washing and I’m comfortable with it lol.

    I’m so sorry to hear that you lost your birth mother. There’s a book by Hope Edelman called Motherless Mothers that you might find interesting. I’m glad your non-bio mum was there for you.

    As you know I started off non-bio and am now also bio. The biggest issue I had with TBB and BFing was that I really wanted our son to be breastfed, and DP really didn’t want to do it (I put it down to CSA issues). I’m glad she BF for 2wks but disappointed she didn’t continue. I fed TBB pretty much all the time after that, and did the bulk of the parenting. Mostly I just felt sad that he wasn’t getting breastmilk (she also hated pumping). And pissed off that I wasn’t pg yet because The Plan was 2 close together and I’d BF both.

    TTG is BF. This has never been any issue for DP. But she’s not as “into” parenting as I am anyway so I guess it’s good that we’re different like that. She has a lovely bond with him, and I am extremely well-bonded with TBB.

    I always hated it when people would say that TBB looked like her, especially when it was her mother. First of all because he is a clone of his donor and doens’t look like her. Second of all is the hurt. It’s so important that he looks like her, so where does it leave me? Or something. It’s kind of hard to describe but wow it hurt and still does when people do it. He has a lot of my mannerisms and people who’ve never met DP just assume that I carried both kids.

    I can’t remember if you have plans for you to carry a baby in the future as well?

  • Still alive. Again. « // May 26, 2009 at 5:58 pm | Reply

    [...] my favourite thing, but hey, whatever. I’ve only had one breastfeeding-themed meltdown since I last posted about that, which is something of an achievement (the fact that it was at 5am is irrelevant) and I’m [...]

Leave a Comment